Skip to main content

The Forced Disappearance of Mahmoud Khalil

 

Last saturday night, Mahmoud Khalil was detained by Department of Homeland Security immigrations agents, and was scheduled for deportation before a federal judge issued a stay to make his case. Khalil is a green card holder, and therefore a legal permanent resident of the United States. When made aware of this by Khalil’s wife, Noor Abdalla, who is 8-months pregnant and a US citizen, the immigration agents threatened to arrest her as well. Khalil has been targeted specifically because of his support of Palestinian liberation, he was a vocal leader of the Columbia student protest against the ongoing genocide being committed by Israel, and funded by the United States.

This is an escalation we should all be paying attention to right now. 

The current President and his administration are justifying this by claiming that Khalil is a “terrorist” and his presence in the country jeopardizes American foreign policy. The claim that supporters of Palestinian liberation are either directly supporting Hamas or that they’re inherently anti-semetic is used widely to discredit activists who want to see an end to the genocide and occupation of Palestine. To address this directly, I quote Khalil himself: “As a Palestinian student, I believe the liberation of the Palestinian people and the Jewish people are intertwined. You cannot achieve one without the other.” This man is not a terrorist, he is a concerned student watching the government fund the destruction of his people. To be clear, Khalil was one of many simply demanding Columbia University divest from Israel. He is a protester. He is a dissenter. He is one of us.

The right to protest is supposedly a protected right in this country, enshrined in the First Amendment. But if you have been on the ground at any sort of escalated protest in the last few years, you know this is a limited right. Peaceful protests are often surveilled by police, with police often confronting and brutalizing participants and protest leaders. We know how this played out here in Minneapolis, but this is true of every American city; especially New York, which has the largest police force and one of the most robust surveillance networks in the world.  

The United States has a long and sordid history of first amendment suppression. From blacklisting government officials during the McCarthy-era hearings, and assassinating Black leaders of the Civil Rights movement to the unregulated surveillance of American citizens under the Patriot Act and the oppression we see today. This is not a new problem, but one that the United States has been denigrating for decades now. In recent years, including under both Obama and Biden, we have seen several extrajudicial killings of political dissenters in this country. 

In 2023, Tortuguita, a Stop Cop City activist and environmental defender, was murdered by Georgia State Patrol troopers during a raid on the Welaunee Forest encampment. Here in Minneapolis: Winston Smith, a vocal Black Liberationist, was assassinated by US Marshalls in 2021. Following the state-sanctioned murder of Michael Brown in 2014, five young Black men who were a part of the Black Lives Matter movement in Feguson were “found dead”: DeAndre Joshua, Darren Seals, Marshawn McCarrel, Edward Crawford Jr. and Dayne Jones. 

The United States is not new to silencing activists, and we need to be honest about where our rights lay, particularly now as we are facing a new, authoritarian vision for our country.  Weaponizing the Department of State to target green card holders for deportation for any reason would already be an escalation; doing so because they dissented and protested at their university is another thing entirely.

There are multiple escalations happening here: yes, we are seeing increased state repression over free speech, overlapping this is the weaponization of deportation against immigrants. It’s not just Khalil, stories of detention and deportations of lawful residents of the US are increasing. We don’t currently have the numbers but we are seeing anecdotally a further escalation of ICE raids and arrests, as well as attacks on Temporary Protected Status from the President and his administration. 

Close to home, we see this escalation playing out in Milwaukee with Ma Yang, a Hmong-American woman and mother of 5, who is currently being detained by ICE and has been deported to Laos; a country she’s never been to with a language she does not speak. Ma Yang, like Mahmoud Khalil, was a green card holder; her status was revoked when she pleaded guilty to a marijuana trafficking charge. Yang is currently being held by military officers in Laos following her arrival, and has no insulin for her diabetes and dwindling supplies of high blood pressure medication.

In the United States deportations and detention have been normalized to an unacceptable degree. These practices are barbaric and horrifying, especially with the conduct of ICE which we have seen play out in horror stories over the last 25 years. As ICE and Department of Homeland Security agents are even more emboldened than ever, it’s critical that we are aware of the escalations happening and act accordingly to protect all of the immigrants in this country that are at risk. Regardless of criminal history, of drug use, of dissent or whatever justification the federal government may use against a person to justify this brutality onto them, we must stand with our immigrant neighbors. 

If you’re looking for a way to tangibly make a difference in the lives of immigrants here in Minnesota: I am linking to a gofundme for the Reyes family, who are raising funds for their father’s immigration case. The funds raised will be used for legal fees, as the family continues to track his case. ICE has already moved the father out of state ahead of his immigration court hearing. This fundraiser is being run by Chenda Hing, a cohort member of Minneapolis’ own Paper Lantern Project, and it is a direct way to help make a difference in the lives of one of our neighbors and ensure that this family is able to stay in this country together.     

I would be remiss if I did not mention that this repression follows after a year’s worth of brutal suppression of pro-Palestinian student protesters across the country, including and especially Columbia University, where Mahmoud Khalil studied. ​​Students around the country have already faced suspensions, expulsions, arrests, and police brutality for their opposition to the genocide in Gaza. This brutality opened the door for more state repression. Biden and a bunch of Democratic city mayors who allowed for these attacks on free speech are more than complicit in where we are at now, and wherever we end up.  

An attack on the freedom to dissent is not just harmful, it is a step on the pathway to full authoritarian control. As the federal government continues to weaponize its power over the most marginal: trans and queer people, immigrants, the working poor; we must all be dissenters. If you cannot dissent from a genocide, if you cannot dissent from the actions of the federal government: there is no functional right to protest.

For further reading on the interconnectedness of these issues, read this piece by Silky Shah for TruthOut.

As I was working on this piece, Kelly Hayes (who if you don’t know, get to reading), wrote on this same topic. I will link to her piece here and finish with a quote that gets to the heart of the issue.

Kelly writes:

“They came for Mahmoud Khalil in the night, and they will come for us, too. They will come with immigration raids. They will come for us with AI searches, scraping our data, and compiling massive lists of political targets. They will come with RICO charges, as they have for Cop City protesters in Atlanta. They will come with bizarre allegations of “fraud.” They will accuse us of supporting and abetting terrorism. They will terrorize us, criminalize us, and attempt to silence us. Now is the time to speak out and to “flood the zone,” as Scot Nakagawa writes. 

As protests and support efforts for Khalil continue, we should all uplift demands for his freedom.

Do what you can, where you can. Do not wait until this violence comes to your doorstep, or until the anguish that is being visited upon Noor Abdalla fills your heart and your home.”

Welcome to this week’s installment of
Ash In Your Corner.
My name is Ash and I am a community organizer, political activist and Trans legal advocate with a proven track record of changing policy and movement building across the world.
I’m bringing my expertise directly to you so that you feel informed and empowered as you navigate the world in your own communities.

Newsletter signup

Sign up to be notified of new posts on this site.

Please wait...

Thank you for signing up!