Skip to main content
news

Ash in Your Corner – Vol. 4

By April 18, 2025No Comments

We need to have a conversation about the rule of law in the United States.

Just a heads up:

This is a bit of a longer read, because I have a lot to say. Please stick with me.

I have been deliberating about how to frame this discussion because there are so many different angles from which this issue is currently taking form. I debated framing this around the upcoming Supreme Court cases I am worried about, or the abduction of Americans to CECOT (the supranational torture prison in El Salvador), or the continued defiance of court orders by the Trump administation.

The conclusion I’ve come to is we need to take a step back and look at all of this together and talk about what this means for the future of our country. 

To start, what is the “rule of law” and why does it matter?

Rule of Law describes principles of a functioning government, particularly a healthy constitutional democracy, that is described by Geoffrey de Q. Walker, as “the people (including, one should add, the government) should be ruled by the law and obey it and the law should be such that people will be able (and, one should add, willing) to be guided by it.”

Below are some examples of how this principle has been expanded through the years to include some particularly specific examples of how this should function in a working democracy, as compiled by the Rule of Law Education Centre, based in Australia:

The rule of law has three fundamental principles that Professor Dicey articulated in his 1885 text Introduction to the Study of the Law of the Constitution. These are:


  1. The absolute supremacy or predominance of the law as opposed to the influence of arbitrary power. It excludes the existence of arbitrariness or prerogative, or even of wider discretionary authority on the part of the government. The people are ruled by the law, and by the law alone; a man may be punished for a breach of law, but he can be punished for nothing else.

  2. Equality for all before the law. Every person no matter their rank or condition is subject to the ordinary law. This excludes the idea of any exemption of officials or others from the duty of obedience to the law. We are all subject to the jurisdiction of the ordinary tribunals.

  3. An independent judiciary that determines people’s rights and obligations under the law.

These three principles remain the foundation of the rule of law today. Since 1885 these principles have been developed further and the rule of law now includes the following principles in practice:

In summary, in a legal system that adheres to the rule of law, the people subject to it, should know what the law is and have reasonable certainty as to the consequences of breaking that law. The same laws should apply to all persons subject to the legal system and any determination of whether the law has been broken and the consequences of any breach, or to determine a party’s rights and obligations, should be conducted by an open and independent judicial system.

Essentially there should be a set of laws that are relatively easy for a populace to understand and follow, these rules should be applied evenly and no one, including the government and those holding government office are exempt from the same set of laws. 

The United States of America has historically not met all of these requirements for all people. Notably Black and Indigenous people in this country have dealt with an unequal application of law and an arbitrary nature to how the judiciary has punished members of these demographic groups. None of what I’m writing about today is meant to undermine the long history of judicial abuse that minority populations in this country have faced through the last 150 years since this doctrine has been developed. The mass incarceration of Black men, the broken treaties and extermination of Indigenous land and people, the internment of Japanese Americans during World War II, the surveillance of Muslims and the illegal torture of Arabs during the Bush years all represent American atrocities and a clear picture that this country has always had a false impression of meeting the standards of a functioning rule of law in the United States.

What I’m writing about here and now—and what we’re all experiencing—are new developments, ones that make clear what path the country is currently on and the risk that path poses to all supposedly free people in the United States.

To recap, in the last few months we have seen (non-exhaustive): 

  • the gutting of large portions of the federal government, 
  • the destruction of information, 
  • the revocation of legal status of students,
  • the abduction of legal residents and citizens,
  • and CECOT – the torture/death prison located in El Salvador that this administration has begun sending people to without any sort of due process.

Scroll back up and look back at the list of principles of rule of law again. Not looking so good here.

Let’s take a second to talk about Kilmar Abrego Garcia, a legal resident and one of countless individuals denied due process and who are now imprisoned thousands of miles away from their family in the El Salvadorian mega-prison. Abrego Garcia was illegally detained by ICE and then deported “erroneously” to CECOT. 

On April 10, 2025, the U.S. Supreme Court unanimously upheld a district court’s ruling requiring the Trump administration to “facilitate” Abrego Garcia’s release from custody in El Salvador. The Supreme Court further directed the District Court to clarify what specific actions the Executive Branch needed to take to “effectuate” his return, and said the government should share with the court its actions taken to return Abrego Garcia. SCOTUS rejected the Trump administration’s defense, which claimed it lacked the legal authority to exercise jurisdiction over El Salvador and secure his return. In the unanimous decision, Justice Sotomayor noted that this argument implied the government “could deport and incarcerate any person, including U.S. citizens, without legal consequence, so long as it does so before a court can intervene.”

In the week since the ruling, Trump’s DOJ has continued to appeal a district court order to facilitate the release of Abrego Garcia. Both Trump and El Salvadorian dictator Nayib Bukele have gone on the record to say they will not release Kilmar, regardless of any court order.

So where does this leave us? Where does this leave Kilmar Abrego Garcia?

In a ruling released April 17, 2025, the 4th Circuit Court of Appeals denied the administration’s appeal of the lower court’s ruling that the government must “facilitate” the release of Abrego Garcia. The court held, “The government is asserting a right to stash away residents of this country in foreign prisons without the semblance of due process that is the foundation of our constitutional order…This should be shocking not only to judges, but to the intuitive sense of liberty.”

So to summarize, we are now at a point where anyone can be illegally detained and sent to a supranational labor camp, and the President and his administration are openly defying orders from courts—up to and including the Supreme Court itself. We have no due process in this. There is no separation of powers. The administration is immune from being held in contempt. Let’s also consider the detention and deportation of student protesters who dissent from the American government’s support of the genocide in Gaza, which brings us to the conclusion, we are all just a wrong word away from this fate ourselves. 

My wife and I listened to Movement Memos together this week. Kelly Hayes was joined by Ejeris Dixon and they discuss fascism, coalition building, and the compassion and shared knowledge we need to create safety and justice in these times. Towards the end of the episode Kelly talks about the new reality we are living under and I want to just quote her, because she is really precise about where exactly this leaves us.

[W]hat you’re saying is making me think about a Masha Gessen piece that I read recently, where Gessen talked about the ways we try to exempt ourselves from disturbing news. We read that someone has been targeted or kidnapped by the state, and we look for the ways that they’re not like us. We look for the transgressions, the missteps, or other differences between their circumstances and ours, in order to feel like maybe we’re still safe—in a world where people are being snatched off the street, in unmarked vehicles, and sent to nightmarish prisons in El Salvador without any due process. It’s a natural thing to feel inclined to do, to try to imagine there’s some version of all of this where we can just lay low, and maybe not be directly impacted. But those illusions are only going to delay the very real work we need to do to create as much safety as we can for ourselves and others during this incredibly dangerous time.

We’re not experiencing a constitutional crisis, we’re experiencing a constitutional collapse. And while it’s true that some people have always been treated unjustly under this system, it’s not like things are going to stay the same for folks who’ve always gotten the worst of it and get worse for everyone else. As a Native person, for example, I know that if conditions are becoming really difficult for suburban white folks, my people are already being left for dead. During early COVID, there were Native medical workers who requested more medical supplies from the federal government and were sent body bags. That’s the reality of how bad times fall on the marginalized.

A lot of things are in free fall right now. We need to be building coalitions and infrastructure to create as much safety and justice as we can. 

This is not the first or last time I will hang my point on the words of Kelly Hayes. If you’re not listening to Movement Memos, or are not subscribed to Truthout’s newsletter, or to Kelly’s own newsletter, Organizing My Thoughts, I really highly recommend them. 

I will also suggest Ejeris Dixon’s own podcast, The Fascism Barometer. This week, Ejeris was joined by Shelby Chestnut, Executive Director of the Transgender Law Center, to talk Trans Liberation in the face of fascism. If you’re interested in getting caught up on the current state of anti-trans attacks across the country, you should really listen in.

“We need to be building coalitions and infrastructure to create as much safety and justice as we can.”  This has been heavily on my mind. I have been feeling really scared about my own safety here in the US, and the safety of my dear friends and family. Who will actually stand up to protect me and my neighbors? How do we build the infrastructure necessary in our communities so none of us are stolen and sent to a death camp? How do we combat a fascist regime that is in full control of the entire government? How do we continue to resist as dissidents are targeted?

I don’t have complete, good answers to these questions. I have thoughts and offerings, I have some skills and lived experience that give me some insight. On top of that, I listen to others, Black and Native women especially, who have guided me through dark times before. 

I invite you to join me in figuring these out together. Together we can build something that can protect us all, but we all need to be putting in the work. 

I ask, where does that work start for you?

Welcome to this week’s installment of
Ash In Your Corner.
My name is Ash and I am a community organizer, political activist and Trans legal advocate with a proven track record of changing policy and movement building across the world.
I’m bringing my expertise directly to you so that you feel informed and empowered as you navigate the world in your own communities.

Newsletter signup

Sign up to be notified of new posts on this site.

Please wait...

Thank you for signing up!